How
can someone who has a chance to get the Triple Crown in the American League,
which has not been done in over forty years, lose the MVP race? When the person
who wins is being compared to an early Mickey Mantle and may be the most spectacular
defensive outfielder we’ve seen in a while.
Mike trout will win the
American League MVP award, just narrowly beating out Miguel Cabrera. No one can
take away what Cabrera might do, which would be winning the Home run, RBI, and
Batting title in one year, but it is not enough to take over what a 21 year old
complete player is doing in his rookie season. The WAR (wins above replacement) stat, though imperfect, may
be the only statistic that can completely judge a players overall value.
Trout is leading the
majors with a 10.4 WAR, which is 3.6 ahead of Cabrera. Cabrera is not even the
highest player on his team; Justin Verlander is in a three way tie for second
in the majors. Even if you do not want to look at WAR, you just need to watch
them play. Mike Trout is on his way to becoming a revolutionary player and is
showing some of the greatest defense in the majors. When it comes to defense,
Trout wins every time. Cabrera is actually one of the worst defensive third
baseman in the majors.
When it comes to
hitting, Cabrera is obviously the better player, but when you dissect some of
the stats, it is not by much. The RBI stat is a bit overrated because it is
more about opportunity than actual skill. The fact the Trout is a leadoff man
means he gets on base more and is not meant to drive in the runs, but score
them. You need to look more into Mike Trout’s game to see the amount of impact
he has on scoring runs.
First of all, Trout is
one of the best base stealers in the game. His success rate is 46 for 50, one
of the best ever with that many attempts. This stops double play opportunities,
which will add in more runs. Also Mike Trout’s defense has saved around 25 runs
from scoring, while Cabrera has not given much added value with any base running
or defense. Then you look that Trout is only .06 behind Cabrera in Batting
Average, which is one of the most important stats for a hitter.
The argument should not
be used as a divider and something to be upset about. The fact that there is
the possibility that we could have one of the greatest hitting performances of
all time, along with one of the greatest all around performances, IN THE SAME
YEAR! My prediction for Mike Trouts Career is that his name will be stated in the same breath as Ken Griffey Jr., Willie Mays, and Mickey Mantle.
So Who is your AL MVP?
All stats are provided by ESPN Stats Page.